There’s a well-known story about C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien’s agreement to write stories about Space and Time. Dissatisfied with the state of Space/Time stories in the 1930s, the two decided to write the kind of stories they wanted to read. Lewis agreed to write a story focused on Space, and Tolkien agreed to write a story focused on Time. Ultimately, Lewis followed through and produced the three books popularly known as his Space Trilogy. Tolkien never quite got around to writing his story about Time, he was too busy finishing some business about a ring.
I relate that story because I was reminded of it as I read about SpaceX and Tesla founder, Elon Musk. I’ve written about Peter Thiel a time or two recently, but Thiel isn’t the only tech entrepreneur with an expansive vision for the future. Whereas Thiel’s interests seem to gravitate toward technologies associated with Transhumanism, however, fellow PayPal alum Elon Musk’s interests are interplanetary in scope. It is as if, not unlike Lewis and Tolkien, Musk and Thiel decided to split up Space and Time between them. They, of course, would do more than write–they would seek to conquer their respective fields. Thiel sets out to conquer Time through the radical human enhancement and Musk sets out to conquer Space through interplanetary colonization. Interestingly enough, the ultimate success of their wildest dreams rather depend on one another.
Musk was recently interviewed by Ross Anderson for Aeon. Anderson’s title for his nearly 7,000 word essay that resulted, “Exodus,” is apt on at least two counts. It encompasses both the central theme of the interview–interplanetary migration for the sake of species survival–and the religious themes evoked by Anderson.
It’s a long, interesting piece, but here are some of the highlights, particularly in light of recent posts considering technological innovation, culture, and the religion of technology.
First, a snapshot of Musk’s stated vision for space travel:
“I had come to SpaceX to talk to Musk about his vision for the future of space exploration, and I opened our conversation by asking him an old question: why do we spend so much money in space, when Earth is rife with misery, human and otherwise? It might seem like an unfair question. Musk is a private businessman, not a publicly funded space agency. But he is also a special case. His biggest customer is NASA and, more importantly, Musk is someone who says he wants to influence the future of humanity. He will tell you so at the slightest prompting, without so much as flinching at the grandiosity of it, or the track record of people who have used this language in the past. Musk enjoys making money, of course, and he seems to relish the billionaire lifestyle, but he is more than just a capitalist. Whatever else might be said about him, Musk has staked his fortune on businesses that address fundamental human concerns. And so I wondered, why space?
Musk did not give me the usual reasons. He did not claim that we need space to inspire people. He did not sell space as an R & D lab, a font for spin-off technologies like astronaut food and wilderness blankets. He did not say that space is the ultimate testing ground for the human intellect. Instead, he said that going to Mars is as urgent and crucial as lifting billions out of poverty, or eradicating deadly disease.
‘I think there is a strong humanitarian argument for making life multi-planetary,’ he told me, ‘in order to safeguard the existence of humanity in the event that something catastrophic were to happen, in which case being poor or having a disease would be irrelevant, because humanity would be extinct.”
While discussing our failure, thus far, to find intelligent life, Musk observed:
“At our current rate of technological growth, humanity is on a path to be godlike in its capabilities.”
He then went on to explain why he thinks we’ve not yet encountered intelligent life:
“Musk has a more sinister theory. ‘The absence of any noticeable life may be an argument in favour of us being in a simulation,’ he told me. ‘Like when you’re playing an adventure game, and you can see the stars in the background, but you can’t ever get there. If it’s not a simulation, then maybe we’re in a lab and there’s some advanced alien civilisation that’s just watching how we develop, out of curiosity, like mould in a petri dish.’ Musk flipped through a few more possibilities, each packing a deeper existential chill than the last, until finally he came around to the import of it all. ‘If you look at our current technology level, something strange has to happen to civilisations, and I mean strange in a bad way,’ he said. ‘And it could be that there are a whole lot of dead, one-planet civilisations.’”
A reminder dropped in by Anderson of the pedigree of Musk’s ambitions:
“In 1610, the astronomer Johannes Kepler wrote, in a letter to Galileo: ‘Let us create vessels and sails adjusted to the heavenly ether, and there will be plenty of people unafraid of the empty wastes. In the meantime, we shall prepare, for the brave sky-travellers, maps of the celestial bodies.'”
And then, toward the end of the piece, Anderson begins to play up the religion of technology jargon (emphasis mine):
“But a million people on Mars sounds like a techno-futurist fantasy, one that would make Ray Kurzweil blush. And yet, the very existence of SpaceX is fantasy. After talking with Musk, I took a stroll through his cathedral-like rocket factory.”
“This fear, that the sacred mission of SpaceX could be compromised, resurfaced when I asked Musk if he would one day go to Mars himself. ‘I’d like to go, but if there is a high risk of death, I wouldn’t want to put the company in jeopardy,’ he told me. ‘I only want to go when I could be confident that my death wouldn’t result in the primary mission of the company falling away.’ It’s possible to read Musk as a Noah figure, a man obsessed with building a great vessel, one that will safeguard humankind against global catastrophe. But he seems to see himself as a Moses, someone who makes it possible to pass through the wilderness – the ‘empty wastes,’ as Kepler put it to Galileo – but never sets foot in the Promised Land.”
You can see why NASA has given Musk a shot at human spaceflight. He makes a great rocket but, more than that, he has the old vision in him. He is a revivalist, for those of us who still buy into cosmic manifest destiny. And he can preach. He says we are doomed if we stay here. He says we will suffer fire and brimstone, and even extinction. He says we should go with him, to that darkest and most treacherous of shores. He promises a miracle.
9 thoughts on “Elon Musk: Prophet of Cosmic Manifest Destiny”
That was really interesting, thank you. Ah, religion jargon and technology, I’ve noticed.
“….humanity is on a path to be godlike in its capabilities.”
I’m quite sure we’re now morally and ethically advanced enough to handle godlike capabilities. No, no, I’m not sure at all.
While your religion, Progressivism, wears the skins of Christrianity (just as Christianity wore the skins of Greco-Roman Paganism) and others… The future Machine Prophets like Elon Musk are wearing the skin of Progressivism…
You’ve certainly given us a lot to think about. I always smile when people think they’re God. It never quite works out that way.
Reblogged this on Tome and Tomb and commented:
There is much to be said for Musk’s Ideas in both the Real World, and in fiction, and even in gaming.
The idea of colonising other planets to preserve humanity has a major problem. We know from our experience with space stations that even relatively limited time spent in a non-Earth environment is hard on the human body. We have no idea what years, or decades might do, and whether it’s possible to counteract the effects. A colony might flounder from simple health problems even if other potential problems could be avoided. Something like the Mars One project sounds like a giant medical experiment, with possibly questionable consent from those involved.
well its not Musk doing the messianic figure thing, its the hidden ones who support and surround him….. if you know anything about the worship of the naked pregnant mother, then you will understand why his mother did this http://assets.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/blog/MayeMusk-pregnant*500.jpg?v=1 and then if you follow the clues you will find out all about….
Not a big fan of this guy, hes into creating “virtual realities” in his subjects…. but he may find that if someone walks upto him and gives him a slap it will still bloody hurt.
His visions are horrible and his escape to Mars would be welcome if he would only take his huge entourage of nutters.
Apart from that he seems alright ;)